top of page

THINKDROP 52: Small Is the New Big.

16 hours ago
8 min read

>Think small. Notice more.


Tiny blue Volkswagen Beetle on a vast white page above the headline Think small, next to the title Small Is the New Big. THINKDROP 52

Every founder I know wants to get big.


Bigger audience. Bigger market. Bigger dashboard. Bigger round.


So they do what everyone does. They stare at the biggest numbers they can find, copy the biggest players, and wonder why everything looks the same.


This week I'm asking you to look at the smallest thing in your business instead.


Small is the new big. Not because big stopped working, but because big is crowded. Everybody has the same reports, the same benchmarks, the same advice.


I'll tell you a small story from my own newsletter at the end. 42 people. One minute. First, the pattern.

Small is not a stage you grow out of. It's an advantage you can choose to keep.


This week is about small data, small claims, small niches, small flavors and small audiences.


Pierre Stanghellini


1. Small Data Sees What Dashboards Miss


Martin Lindstrom wrote Small Data: The Tiny Clues That Uncover Huge Trends (St. Martin's Press, 2016). His method: go into people's homes and notice the details nobody puts in a spreadsheet. According to the publisher, he spends about 300 nights a year doing it.


His best-known story is Lego. Around 2004, by his account, every big-data study said children of the digital age were too impatient for building bricks, and management considered making the bricks bigger. Then his team visited an 11-year-old boy in Germany. Asked what he was proudest of, the boy pointed to a worn pair of Adidas skate shoes. The wear was proof of his skill. Kids, it turned out, will put in hours on something hard if mastery earns them respect.


Lego went back to normal-size bricks, added smaller ones and made the builds harder. Lindstrom says sales rose 11% to over $2 billion in the first half of 2014, and Lego passed Mattel as the world's largest toy maker.


Big data told Lego what the average child does. One child explained why. Lindstrom also points out that companies reading the same big data tend to end up heading the same way.


To be fair: this is Lindstrom's own telling, and one boy is not a sample. Lindstrom himself says the ideal is big data and small data together. Small data gives you a hypothesis. It doesn't prove it.


I found this book in a second-hand bookshop in Stanley Market, Hong Kong, where the books sell for HK$10. That was my best investment.


You can buy the same report as your competitor. You can't buy the sentence your client said on Tuesday.


Try this: This week, write down three small things clients said or did: a hesitation, a word they repeat, a question they asked twice. Then look for what the three have in common.


2. Think Small. Literally.


The famous ad with the tiny car, the Volkswagen Beetle, 1959.

It's one of my favorite ads of all time. Super impactful. Pure creativity, the kind that defined 1960s advertising.


American cars of the time were big and glossy. The agency DDB, with copywriter Julian Koenig and art director Helmut Krone, did the opposite: a small photo of the Beetle, a lot of white space, and a headline that said Think Small. The ad leaned into what looked like the car's weakness. Advertising Age later ranked the Volkswagen campaign number one of the twentieth century.


Why it worked: it was honest. The car was small, the ad was small, and the match felt true. On a magazine page full of loud illustrations, the quiet one stopped the reader.


To be fair: shrinking your message only works if what you say is true.

A tiny ad for a mediocre product is just a tiny ad. ;-)


Small only works when it's true.


Try this: Take your next offer, post or pitch and cut it down to one claim you can prove. Delete the rest.


3. Pick an Attitude. Then Don't Outgrow It.


When BMW relaunched the Mini in 2001, Marketing Week pointed to a problem: the car had no specific target market. Other accounts describe two groups: affluent 20-to-34-year-olds, and 35-to-50-year-olds with fond memories of the original. The agency, Crispin Porter + Bogusky, aimed at drivers who value self-expression, humor and openness, whatever their age. The niche was an attitude, not a demographic. Even Mini's own PR chief has said the brand is happy to be a niche.


Hummer tells the other half of the story. The civilian H1 went on sale in 1992 and about 11,800 were built by 2006. A real niche. Then GM added the H2 (2002) and the H3 (2005). Hummer sales peaked at 71,524 in 2006, fell to just over 9,000 in 2009 and to 265 in January 2010. GM announced the end of the brand in February 2010.


I won't pretend one chart explains it. Record fuel prices and a cultural backlash did real damage by 2008. But here is my reading, and it's an inference, not a proven cause: a brand built on being extreme grew into a mass product, and a mass audience is the first to leave when the mood changes.


To be fair: Mini grew too, adding models for more target groups. What it kept was the attitude.


Choose who you're for by how they think, not how old they are.


Try this: Describe your five best clients without age, job title or sector. What attitude do they share? Write it in one sentence.


4. The Weirdest Flavor in the Freezer


The last ice cream that impressed me was a hay ice cream. Organic. Sold by an ice-cream seller in Saint-Emlion last summer, near my home in France.


THINKDROP 48 told you vanilla is dead. This is the small-batch version of that idea.


Nobody is trying to please everyone with hay ice cream. It filters. People who want it will go and find it. People who don't aren't lost customers, because they were never the audience. And the seller isn't playing the supermarket's game.


A strange flavor gets remembered. That's its job.


To be fair: memorable is not the same as profitable. Someone has to come back for a second scoop, and I know nothing about this seller's numbers. A niche that's too small is a hobby.


Be the flavor a few people remember, not the one everybody tolerates.


Try this: Name the one odd, specific thing you do that most of your market would find strange. Put it on your homepage this week.


5. Count Your Fans, Not Your Followers


In 2008 Kevin Kelly published an essay called "1,000 True Fans". The math: if a thousand people each pay you about $100 a year, that's $100,000. A thousand customers is far more realistic to aim for than a million. He argues that even a one-in-a-million appeal can find 1,000 people online.


I run my own small test of this. THINKDROP's goal is 1,000 subscribers on LinkedIn. At the start of November, 3,564 people followed my profile there. 293 subscribed to THINKDROP. The second number is the one I count.


To be fair: 1,000 isn't sacred. Investor Li Jin argued in 2020 that 100 fans paying $1,000 a year can be the better model. The point is the shape: few, close, committed.


A thousand people who care beat a million who scroll.


Try this: Write down the names of your ten most engaged readers, clients or contacts.

If you can't, you have an audience you don't know yet.


5-Point Recap


  • Collect small clues. The detail your client gave you is the one thing a competitor can't buy.

  • Say less. One provable claim stops more readers than ten loud ones.

  • Choose an attitude. Who you're for matters more than how old they are.

  • Price your growth. Before you widen your audience, list what it would change about you.

  • Count real fans. A thousand people who care beat a million who scroll.


Food for Thought


Big is easy to measure. That's why we chase it. Small is harder to measure, so it's still cheap, and still early.


Look back at this issue. Lindstrom found Lego's answer in one boy's worn skate shoes. Volkswagen won by shrinking a photo. Mini kept an attitude, and Hummer grew out of one. A hay ice cream finds its few people. A thousand fans can be enough.


None of these is really a story about being tiny. Each one is about being specific, and staying specific when growth gives you a good reason to blur.


That's the hard part. Small is easy to start and hard to protect. Every request to widen the audience, soften the claim or add one more flavor will sound reasonable. Ask what it costs you before you say yes.


Small data has a price too. It takes time, it doesn't scale and you can't paste it into a slide. That's exactly why it's still early. The 42 unsubscribes below only became a clue when I opened the individual records instead of trusting the total.


Big is a number. Small is a face.


What is the smallest detail about your best client that nobody on your team can explain?


What would you stop doing if you decided to stay small on purpose?


Which big number are you chasing only because it's the easiest one to measure?


Tell me on LinkedIn.


Stay small enough to notice.


Pierre Stanghellini

→ Let's connect, drop me a line directly at pierre@hari.wtf.


YOU LIKED IT ?? Share with friends and let's expand our community!

Once THINKDROP reaches 1,000 subscribers on LinkedIn, I'll launch the THINKDROP Conference! It's going to be amazing!



Cas Pratique: 42 People in One Minute


On 1 November, I had 42 people put back on the THINKDROP list.

The system said they had all unsubscribed.


What gave it away wasn't a rate. Forty-two unsubscribes is just a number. What gave it away was the timestamps: all 42 unsubscribe records were created on 6 October, between 05:04 and 05:05 UTC, four days after I sent THINKDROP 47.


People don't leave a newsletter in the same minute. Real churn trickles. This was one event.


I don't know yet what created those records. An automated process is the suspect, and the technical team is checking.


The effect was concrete. THINKDROP 51 went to an audience of 371 instead of 329. Forty-two readers, more than one in ten, would have been left out.

I'm now watching for the same pattern after every send.


Your turn: The Odd-Detail Audit


Use it on any number you check every week.


  1. Pick one number. A figure you track weekly: list size, churn, orders.

  2. Go one level down. Open the individual records behind it.

  3. Sort by time. Look for events that cluster. Real behavior is messy; a tidy cluster is a clue.

  4. Ask what would make it normal. Write down the one thing that would have to be true.

  5. Ask a human. Message one person behind the record and ask.


If two of the five steps turn up something you can't explain, stop optimizing the headline number and investigate that detail first.


Questions about this audit? pierre@hari.wtf


FAQ: Small Is the New Big

What does "small is the new big" mean in business?


It means competitive advantage is moving toward small, specific things: detailed customer observations, narrow niches and small committed audiences. Large datasets and mass audiences are available to everyone, so they differentiate less. The idea doesn't say big has stopped working, only that big is crowded.


What is small data, and how is it different from big data?


Small data is the little behavioral detail you notice in real life, like a habit, a gesture or an object in someone's home. Big data is large-scale statistics showing what many people do. Martin Lindstrom, who popularized the term in his 2016 book Small Data, argues the best results come from combining the two.


How many customers do you need to build a niche business?


There is no fixed number. Kevin Kelly's "1,000 True Fans" essay gives one example: 1,000 customers each paying about $100 a year equals $100,000. The right number depends on what each customer is worth to you.



About the Creator

Pierre Stanghellini is a creative strategist, systems thinker, and curator of mental rabbit holes. He created Thinkdrop Weekly to feed the brains that don't want the same old Business advice. If you're building something bold, beautiful, or strange, this is your corner of the internet.



About HARi.wtf

HARi.wtf is a creative strategy studio for businesses that hate business-as-usual. Born in Hong Kong in 2016, we work with restless founders, operators, and teams who'd rather break things thoughtfully than grow them blandly.


Explore more at HARi.wtf


Comments


bottom of page